Do I Have to Attend the Insurance Company’s Medical Exam?

Usually yes, when the request is a proper one. Florida’s no-fault statute lets your own Personal Injury Protection carrier, through your own car insurance, require a medical examination where your condition is material to the claim, and once a lawsuit is filed the party defending it can seek an examination under the rules of civil procedure. Refusing without a good reason can cost you benefits.

That said, the request has limits, and they are worth knowing before the date arrives. There are rules about where a PIP examination can be held, what a litigation request has to specify, and what the party asking has to show. If something about the appointment is genuinely unworkable, it is raised through your lawyer rather than by not showing up.

An empty medical office waiting area in South Florida, illustrating an insurance medical exam in a car accident claim

What an Insurance Medical Exam Is in Florida

An insurance medical exam is an examination of an injured person arranged by the side evaluating or defending the claim, performed by a physician that the side selects and pays. It is not treatment. The physician forms an opinion about your condition and writes a report, and does not prescribe care, order follow-up or manage your recovery in any way.

You may see it called an independent medical examination. In Florida the working term is a compulsory medical examination, which describes the arrangement more plainly, because attendance can be required and the examining physician is chosen by the requesting side rather than agreed on by both. Our blog on what a compulsory medical examination means for your claim covers the process in more depth.

When an Insurance Medical Exam Comes Up in a Florida Claim

There are two distinct stages. Before any lawsuit, your own PIP carrier, through your own car insurance, can request one while it decides what to pay, often after several months of treatment or when billing crosses a level the carrier wants reviewed. After a lawsuit is filed, the party being sued can seek an examination through the court.

They are routine rather than a signal that something has gone wrong. Injury claims turn on medical opinion, and given the volume of collisions reflected in the crash and citation reports published by the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, carriers handling files across Broward County and Palm Beach County review a great deal of treatment each year.

Who Can Require You to Attend an Insurance Medical Exam

Because Florida operates under a no-fault insurance system, your own PIP coverage, through your own car insurance, pays your medical bills first, generally 80% of reasonable medical expenses and, if your policy includes wage loss coverage, 60% of lost gross income and loss of earning capacity, within one $10,000 limit. Generally, you must seek medical treatment within 14 days of the crash and receive emergency medical care to receive the full extent of those benefits.

Under section 627.736 of the Florida Statutes, where your condition is material to that claim you are to submit to examination on the insurer’s request, and the cost is borne entirely by the insurer. The location is limited: the examination must be within the municipality where you are receiving treatment, or another reasonably accessible place, which the statute defines as your own municipality or within 10 miles by road of your home.

In a filed lawsuit the authority is different. The rule of civil procedure allows a party to request an examination when the condition is in controversy, and the request has to specify a reasonable time, place, manner, conditions and scope along with who will perform it. The examination is authorized only where the requesting party has good cause, and that party carries the burden of showing it. Either side may also ask the court to set protective rules.

What Happens If You Skip an Insurance Medical Exam

On the PIP side the consequences are written into the statute. An unreasonable refusal to submit to an examination, or a failure to appear, means the carrier is no longer liable for subsequent PIP benefits, and refusing or failing to appear at two examinations raises a rebuttable presumption that the refusal or failure was unreasonable. That is a significant risk to run over a scheduling conflict.

In a filed case the court is involved instead, and a party who will not comply with a properly obtained examination can face consequences in the litigation. In both settings the practical answer is the same. A date that does not work, a location outside the statutory radius or a scope that reaches beyond the injuries at issue is raised with the other side or the court in advance, through your lawyer, rather than handled by not appearing.

What to Expect at an Insurance Medical Exam

Most appointments are short. You complete intake paperwork, then answer questions about the crash, your medical history, your current symptoms and what you can and cannot do in an ordinary day. A physical examination usually follows, with range of motion, strength and reflex testing for the body parts at issue, and the physician will often have reviewed records and imaging sent in advance.

Arrive on time, bring identification and a current medication list, and answer the questions accurately, without overstating or understating what you feel. Everything you say becomes part of a written report, so consistency with what your own medical records already show is what matters most. The same caution applies to a recorded statement given to an insurer.

Whether someone may accompany you or record the appointment depends on the setting. In a filed case the rule contemplates it, and the request or response has to state the number of people attending, their role and the method of recording, with the court able to set protective rules. It is a question to settle with your lawyer before the date rather than at the front desk.

How the Insurance Medical Exam Report Affects Your Claim

The report is an opinion on three things: whether the injury came from the crash, whether the treatment was reasonable and necessary, and whether anything about the condition is permanent. A favorable one can move a file along. An unfavorable one is typically used to argue that some treatment should not be paid or that you had recovered earlier than the records suggest, which can also shorten the period covered by a claim for lost income.

In the PIP setting, the statute puts a limit on that. An insurer may not withdraw payment to a treating physician, without your consent, unless it first obtains a report from a Florida physician licensed under the same chapter as that treating physician stating the care was not reasonable, related or necessary. You are also generally entitled to request the report.

Fault works separately from all of this. Florida follows a modified comparative negligence rule, so being more than 50% at fault bars any recovery from any party, and otherwise the award is reduced by your share of fault, which is a different question from what the examination found. Being partly at fault does not by itself end a claim, and in a motor vehicle accident claim the report is weighed against your treating records rather than treated as the final word. Florida generally gives you two years from the date of the crash to file a negligence lawsuit against the at-fault party.

Summary of Insurance Medical Exam Rules in Florida

Attendance is usually required, and most of the risk comes from not knowing the rules around it. The essential points are:

  • Your own PIP carrier can require an examination where your condition is material to the claim, at its own expense.
  • An examination requested by your PIP carrier must be reasonably accessible, defined by municipality or within 10 miles by road of your home.
  • After a lawsuit is filed, the defending party may seek an examination and must show good cause for it.
  • An unreasonable refusal or a failure to appear can end the carrier’s liability for later PIP benefits.
  • You are generally entitled to request the written report.
  • Florida generally gives you two years from the date of the crash to file a negligence lawsuit against the at-fault party.

FAQs About Attending an Insurance Medical Exam

Can I refuse to attend the insurance company’s medical exam?

You can decline, but on the PIP side an unreasonable refusal or a failure to appear means the carrier is no longer liable for subsequent benefits. Missing two examinations raises a rebuttable presumption that the refusal was unreasonable, so a problem with the appointment is better raised in advance.

Who pays for the examination?

In the PIP setting, the statute places the entire cost on the insurer that requested it. The insurer also selects the physician, and you are not asked to agree to that choice, which is the part most people find surprising about the process.

How far can they make me travel for a PIP examination?

The statute requires a reasonably accessible location, meaning the municipality where you are receiving treatment, the municipality where you live, or within 10 miles by road of your home. A location outside that range is worth raising with your lawyer before the date.

Can I bring someone with me or record the appointment?

It depends on the setting. In a filed case, the rule contemplates attendance and recording, and the request or response must state who is attending, their role and the recording method, with the court able to set protective rules. Settle it beforehand.

Will the examination report decide my claim?

No. It is evidence, weighed against your treating records, imaging and the physicians who managed your care. It can support arguments that reduce what a carrier will pay, which is why what you say at the appointment should match what your records already show.

Contact a South Florida Car Accident Lawyer

If an insurance company has scheduled a medical examination in your claim, the team at Lawlor, White & Murphey can explain what to expect and what the report may be used for. We represent injured people throughout Florida, including Broward and Palm Beach County. You can call our office at 954-525-2345. Our office is located at 2211 Davie Boulevard, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.